theory on Snape

[PotionsGirl]

he is not evil because:

Dumbledore and him had a plan that Snape would have to kill him to help Harry fight voldermort, DD is not stupid and knows what he is doing. When he died they creamated him and maybe he could come back like a phoenix, but even if he doesn't come back Snape could be on "Voldies side" to help the Order.

I reaaaly want to think he is not evil. this theory is pretty good, anyone like to expand it?

[lifedrinker]

i agree, i don't think he's evil. i read somewhere that that whole "black hand" thing was because voldemort was somehow connected to dumbledore, somehow controlling him or reading his thoughts or something. using DD to get to harry. snape killed DD to protect harry, methinks...

[PotionsGirl]

oooh that is a good theory cuz DD is always trying to protect him. he also might of thought that if he was alive Harry would never learn how to get a long on his own, and his hatred toward snape would help him kill voldermort